2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior vs 2004 BMW R 1200CL vs 2004 BMW R 1200CL

Full specifications comparison • 3 motorcycles

Comparing 3 motorcycles
2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior

Custom / cruiser

Engine
Four stroke, 48° V-Twin, OHV, 4 valves per cylinder
Power
62 kW / 84.3 hp @ 4400 rpm
Top Speed
N/A
Weight
298.4 kg / 658 lbs
2004 BMW R 1200CL 2004 BMW R 1200CL

Custom / cruiser

Engine
Two cylinder boxer, four-stroke
Power
44.5 kW / 61 hp @ 5000 rpm
Top Speed
165.0 km/h
Weight
308 kg / 679 lbs
2004 BMW R 1200CL 2004 BMW R 1200CL

Touring

Engine
Two cylinder boxer
Power
44.5 kW / 61 hp @ 5000 rpm
Top Speed
164.8 km/h / 102.4 mph
Weight
308 kg / 679 lbs
Full Specifications
General
Year2002 - 052003 - 04
Colours-Silver, Blue, Brown
Make ModelYamaha XV 1700PC Road Star WarriorBMW R 1200CL
Dimensions
Seat Height715 mm / 28.1 in745 mm / 29.3 in
Wheelbase1666.2 mm / 65.6 in1641 mm / 64.6 in
Ground Clearance155 mm / 6.1 in-
Height1115 mm / 43.91435 mm / 56.1 in
Length2385 mm / 93.9 in2415 mm / 95.0 in
Width934.7 mm / 36.81075 mm / 42.3 in
Weights & Capacities
Dry Weight275. kg / 606.2 lbs289 kg / 637 lbs
Fuel Capacity15 Litres / 4.0 US gal17.5 Litres / 4.5 gal
Wet Weight298.4 kg / 658 lbs308 kg / 679 lbs
Performance
Top Speed-164.8 km/h / 102.4 mph
Max Power62 kW / 84.3 hp @ 4400 rpm44.5 kW / 61 hp @ 5000 rpm
Max Torque135 Nm / 99.5 lb-ft @ 3750 rpm98 Nm / 10.0 kgf-m / 72.27 lb-ft @ 3000 rpm
Power-to-Weight Ratio-0.2118 HP/kg
Standing Start ¼ Mile12.7 sec / 103 mph14.7 sec
Engine
Stroke-4
Engine Type-Two cylinder boxer, four-stroke
CO2-118.3 CO
Fuel Control-SOHC
Displacement1670 cc / 101.9 cu-in1170 cc / 71.4 cu in.
Engine DetailFour stroke, 48° V-Twin, OHV, 4 valves per cylinderFour stroke, two cylinder horizontally opposed Boxer, 4 valves per cylinder
Fuel System-Injection
Bore x Stroke97 x 113mm101 x 73mm
Compression Ratio8.3:110.0:1
Cooling SystemAir cooledAir/Oil cooled
Fuel Consumption38.3 mpg5.1 L/100 km / 19.8 km/l / 46.5 US mpg
Fuel InductionTwin-bore fuel injection (FI)Bosch Motronic MA 2.4 Fuel injection
Fuel Reserve-4.00 litres / 1.06 gallons
IgnitionElectronic control unit (ECU) Digital CDI Bosch Electronic
LubricationSemi-dry sumpWet sump
StarterElectricElectric
Valve System-4
EV Specifics
Battery Capacity-BMW Mareg, 19.5 Amp/h low maintenance
Drivetrain
Clutch-Dry, single plate, hydraulic operated
Final DriveBeltShaft
Gear Ratios-1st 2.045 / 2nd 1.600 / 3rd 1.267 / 4th 1.038 / 5th 0.800:1
Gearbox-5-speed
Transmission / Drive5 Speed 5 Speed
Chassis
Frame Type-Three section composite frame consisting of front & rear section, load bearing engine
Suspension - Front41mm Kayaba inverted telescopic fork withMotorrad Telelever, stanchion ∅35mm, central strut
Suspension - RearLink-type, preload and rebound adjustable single rear shockDie cast aluminium single sided swinging arm with BMW Motorrad Monolever, WAD strut (travel related damping), spring preload adjustable to continuously variable levels by means of hydraulic handwheel.
Rake29°-
Trail129.5 mm / 5.1 in86 mm / 3.4 in
Wheel Travel - Front135 mm / 5.3 in145 mm / 5.7 in
Wheel Travel - Rear110 mm / 4.3 in110 mm / 4.3 in
Electrical Systems
Charging System-14 V 50 Amp Alternator (700 W)
Wheels & Brakes
Brakes - Rear Diameter (mm)-285 mm
Brakes - Rear Diameter (in.)-11.2 inches
Brakes - Front Diameter (mm)-305 mm
Brakes - Front Diameter (in.)-12.0 inches
Brakes - Front2x 298 mm discs 4 piston calipers2 x ∅305mm discs, 4 piston calipers
Brakes - RearSingle 282 mm disc 1 piston caliperSingle ∅285mm disc, 2 piston caliper
Tyres - Front120/70 ZR18100/90-18
Tyres - Rear200/50 ZR17170/80-15
Wheels - Front-2.50 x 18, 5-spoke alloy
Wheels - Rear-4.00 x 15, 5-spoke alloy

Verdict

Winner on specs

2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior

The 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior edges out the 2004 BMW R 1200CL thanks to its higher torque, lower seat height and larger displacement. Specifications are one part of the picture - dealer support, parts availability, and intended use all matter too.

Key Differences

2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior - Advantages

  • Higher torque: 135 Nm vs 98 Nm - more pulling power across the rev range.
  • Lower seat height: 715 mm vs 745 mm - accessible to a wider range of rider heights.
  • Larger displacement: 1670 cc vs 1170 cc - more cubic capacity means broader torque delivery and greater low-end pull.

2004 BMW R 1200CL - Advantages

  • Dual front discs: Greater stopping power and better heat management under hard braking.
  • More front wheel travel: 145 mm vs 135 mm - greater compliance over rough surfaces.

2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior vs 2004 BMW R 1200CL - FAQs

What are the engine differences between the 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior and 2004 BMW R 1200CL?
The 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior uses Four stroke, 48° V-Twin, OHV, 4 valves per cylinder, while the 2004 BMW R 1200CL is powered by Two cylinder boxer.
Which bike is better for shorter riders, the 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior or the 2004 BMW R 1200CL?
The 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior has the lower seat at 715 mm, making it more accessible. The 2004 BMW R 1200CL sits higher at 745 mm. A seat height below 800 mm suits most riders; above 820 mm shorter riders may need to tiptoe.
Which should I buy, the 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior or the 2004 BMW R 1200CL?
Both are strong choices. The 2005 Yamaha XV 1700PC Road Star Warrior has the edge in higher torque and lower seat height, while the 2004 BMW R 1200CL stands out for dual front discs and higher front wheel travel. Visit dealers, arrange test rides, and factor in local parts and service costs - these often matter as much as the spec sheet.